International commercial complaint and dispute file
A COMPLAINT AGAINST AMPLUS
WE SHIPPED 8 TRUCKLOADS OF CITRUS. €73,993.91 REMAINS UNPAID.
In our citrus trade with Poland-based AMPLUS Sp. z o.o., the post-delivery quality claims first reported at 10–20% were raised to 50–70% about a month later. Following these disputed assessments, which we did not accept, an outstanding invoice balance of €73,993.91 remains unpaid.
- €133,383.20Total amount invoiced
- €59,389.29Amount received
- €73,993.91Outstanding invoice balance
- 8 TRUCKSCitrus shipments
Why were the quality claims raised a month later?
The defect rate reported for each shipment. The initial assessments we considered reasonable.
The defect rate reported later. Disputed quality deductions we did not accept.
Anatomy of a commercial relationship
Chronology of Events
- 01
Commercial Agreement
Citrus trade between Türkiye and Poland.
- 02
Shipments
Eight truckloads of goods dispatched.
- 03
First Quality Notices
A 10–20% defect rate reported after delivery.
- 04
About One Month Later
Defect rates reported as raised to 50–70%.
- 05
Pricing Objection
The goods stated to have been sold at €0.02 per unit.
- 06
Payment Dispute
An outstanding invoice balance of €73,993.91.
Documents and evidence
Every Document
Shared Transparently
Shipments, invoices, correspondence, quality notices and payment records — all supporting documentation is open to review.
View the document archiveThe card images above are illustrative placeholders. Documents are added to the archive once personal data has been masked in accordance with the law.
Summary
What happened, in three steps
The whole process can be summarised in three stages, each supported by commercial documents.
- 1
Agreement and shipment
A citrus supply agreement was concluded on 24 March 2026. Eight truckloads were shipped to Poland and invoiced for a total of €133,383.20. The sale was direct and at a fixed price — not on commission or consignment.
- 2
A late defect notice
After delivery, a defect rate of 10–20% was reported for each shipment; we considered this reasonable. However, about a month later that rate was raised to 50–70% and we were told the goods had been sold at ≈€0.02.
- 3
A unilateral deduction
As a condition for paying the balance, discount (credit note) documents were demanded. We felt compelled to issue them, then stated in writing that we did not accept them. Our last email of 15 July 2026 has received no reply.
Commercial timeline
From the first agreement to today
Events in chronological order; each step is supported by the relevant commercial documents.
- 24 March 2026A citrus supply agreement was concluded. Orders were placed via email and AMPLUS's own system.
- DeliveriesEight truckloads were shipped to Poland and invoiced — €133,383.20 in total. The shipments were officially recorded via the Turkish Customs Declaration.
- After deliveryA defect rate of 10–20% was reported for each shipment, with a statement that the goods would be “reworked.” We considered this reasonable.
- ≈ 1 month laterThe defect rate was raised to 50–70% and we were told the goods had been sold at ≈€0.02. This is far below even the transport and customs cost of the product (≈€0.30).
- Discount demandAs a condition for paying the balance, discount (credit note) documents were requested.
- Written objectionWe stated in writing that we did not accept the deductions and that they were unfounded.
- 15 July 2026Our last email was sent. To date, no reply has been received.
What we rely on
Not allegations — documents
The records on which our claim rests. Personal data (signatures, IBAN, tax numbers, third-party details) is masked in accordance with the law.
- D-01Customs DeclarationExporter and buyer details; the official record of deliveryAvailable
- D-02Commercial InvoicesShow the €133,383.20 total debt and the fixed priceIn preparation
- D-03Payment ReceiptsConfirm the €59,389.29 collected and clarify the balanceIn preparation
- D-04CMR Transport DocsEvidence the delivery date — showing the defect notice was lateCritical
- D-05CorrespondenceDefect notice, discount demand and our written objectionCritical
- D-06Credit Note + ObjectionShow the discount was imposed and rejectedIn preparation
The buyer
Who is AMPLUS Sp. z o.o.?
Provided solely to identify the counterparty; all details are taken from the company's own public sources and official registry records.
- Legal nameAMPLUS Sp. z o.o.
- Head officeNiegardów 26, 32-104 Koniusza / Poland
- VAT / NIPPL6820002923
- KRS0000626604
- ActivityFresh fruit & vegetable supply
- ExperienceSince 1992 (30+ years)
Why this section is here
AMPLUS Sp. z o.o. is one of Poland's established companies in fresh fruit and vegetable production and distribution, operating since 1992.
This section is compiled solely to identify the counterparty to the dispute and contains no value judgement.
Sector and legal context
This is not an isolated case
The dispute is framed by international rules and established trade practice.
- 1
A defect must be notified “within a reasonable time”
Under the Vienna Sales Convention, to which both Türkiye and Poland are parties, the buyer must notify a defect within the shortest reasonable time after taking delivery. For perishable goods such as citrus, this period is measured in days; a notice arriving about a month after delivery is, by this standard, considered late.
Source — CISG Arts. 38–39 - 2
Unilateral, retroactive discounts are sanctioned in Poland
Imposing a unilateral discount or deduction on a supplier after goods have been delivered is treated as an unfair trading practice in Poland and is heavily penalised by the Office of Competition and Consumer Protection (UOKiK).
Note: these fines concern other companies and are cited here only as sector context, to show the legal character of this type of practice.
Source — Poland's UOKiK · EU UTP Directive 2019/633 - 3
A quality claim requires an independent expert report
The sector rules of the European fresh produce trade require the buyer to obtain an approved, independent expert report for a quality claim. A deduction based on a unilateral statement does not comply with this procedure.
Source — COFREUROP / CAIFL
In the same position? We wrote a guide
If a foreign buyer has withheld payment for goods you delivered, we set out seven steps worth taking — CISG notice deadlines, the credit-note trap, letters of demand, interest, and the legal routes available.
To the management of AMPLUS Sp. z o.o.
We request that this loss be made good
We ask the management of AMPLUS Sp. z o.o. to pay the outstanding balance of €73,993.91. Our aim is resolution — we remain open at all times to a written, fair and documented settlement.
The right of reply is open: any statement from AMPLUS Sp. z o.o., once sent to us, will be published on this page unchanged and with equal prominence. Only official messages from AMPLUS Sp. z o.o. will receive a reply at this address.
iletisim@fairtradevoice.comFAQ
Frequently asked questions
How much did AMPLUS Sp. z o.o. fail to pay?
Is this a defamation campaign?
Why don't you state your full company name?
Why publish online instead of pursuing legal action?
Will the page be removed if payment is made?
How this page was prepared
It has been published in good faith, under the following principles.
- Document-based. Every figure, date and event is supported by commercial documents; it contains no unverified allegation or imputation of a crime.
- Measured. The purpose is not defamation, but to record a commercial dispute, raise awareness and encourage a fair resolution.
- Right of reply is open. Any statement from AMPLUS Sp. z o.o., if sent to us, will be published here unchanged and with equal prominence.
- All legal rights reserved. This statement does not preclude our administrative and legal remedies; it is complementary to them.